Homework battles, shutdowns, and "I don't care" can leave families worn out. Many caregivers wonder what is going on underneath and how to help without every evening turning into an argument.
Cartwheel's November family webinar explored those questions with Emily Edlynn, PhD, a licensed clinical psychologist, international speaker, and author of Autonomy-Supportive Parenting: Reduce Parental Burnout and Raise Competent, Confident Children. Dr. Edlynn shared research-based ideas for helping children and teens feel capable, connected, and more in charge of their own learning.
Why does my child resist homework or school?
Dr. Edlynn explained that resistance often has more than one cause, and a child's effort or character is rarely the whole story. Traditional school settings do not always match how children love to learn, she noted. For a closer look at student engagement, she pointed families to The Disengaged Teen by Jenny Anderson and Rebecca Winthrop. It describes four learning modes: passengers who coast, achievers who work for grades, resistors who push back, and explorers who learn out of curiosity. Children can move between these modes over time.
Executive functioning, the part of the brain that works like a "CEO" for attention, planning, and organization, also plays a role. Children do not need a diagnosis to find these skills hard. Forgetting homework, finishing it but not turning it in, trouble getting started, and rushing through are common patterns. When struggles build, Dr. Edlynn noted, they can lead to conflict at home, more negative feelings about school, and thoughts like "I'm bad at school," which lowers motivation.
What is autonomy-supportive parenting, and how does it help?
Autonomy-supportive parenting pairs clear expectations with a real voice for children. Dr. Edlynn described it as nurturing three needs: autonomy (choice and agency), competence (feeling capable), and relatedness (feeling connected and safe with caring adults). The approach sits in a "Goldilocks" middle between permissive parenting, with very few limits, and controlling parenting, with rigid rules and the use of shame, threats, or bribes. Research Dr. Edlynn reviewed links controlling approaches with more anxiety and low mood.
Every family moves along this range at times, Dr. Edlynn shared. The goal is for children to feel, in general, that they have a voice. Research connects this approach with better grades, more positive attitudes toward school, and more engagement.
What can families try this week?
- Ask what matters. Invite children to share what is important to them about school.
- Lead with curiosity. Open questions such as "When you sit down to do homework, what happens for you?" can help. Working through our own frustration with another adult first, she noted, makes it easier to come to the conversation without judgment.
- Match expectations to skills. Goals that feel out of reach can lead to shutting down, and work that is too easy can lead to boredom.
- Build the routine together. Children can help decide when, where, and in what order homework happens. At her own home, a second grader made a whiteboard list of homework, chores, and things he wanted to do, chose the order, and checked items off.
- Invite instead of demand. "When is a good time for you to start your homework?" keeps the expectation and offers a choice.
- Share the load. Children can email a teacher about makeup work or extra credit, which builds confidence.
How can families keep the relationship at the center?
Dr. Edlynn closed with a reminder that "the relationship is everything" and lasts a lifetime. Families are encouraged to accept children where they are and for who they are, even if they are not the student we pictured. In the big picture, the learning process and the relationship come before grades, test scores, and college admissions.
Family Questions: What Caregivers Wanted to Know
How can I help my child who gives up easily or gets overwhelmed by challenging tasks?
This is common, and Dr. Edlynn noted that it can have several causes. Perfectionism is one: if a child feels they cannot do something perfectly, they may avoid it or shut down.
Dr. Edlynn's suggestion is to make "thinner slices" of challenge, with smaller steps that help children get used to working through frustration. Some families ask teachers about fewer problems when a child has shown mastery. The work still gets done, and the amount can grow over time.
How do we know when to involve the school versus handling struggles at home?
A good partnership with the teacher helps, Dr. Edlynn said, especially in the younger years. With elementary-age children, she suggested holding off on correcting homework so the teacher can see what the child has and has not mastered. Families can share what they see at home and ask what is happening in class and whether the teacher has concerns about learning. When children need more school support, schools often reach out to families to make a plan.
How can I help my teen with time management and follow-through? Do planners help?
For Dr. Edlynn, the answer depends on the teen, and it often takes a series of experiments. Buy-in matters, because tools tend to work better when teens feel ownership. A good first step is asking whether they find time hard to manage and whether they want help. Planners work for teens who use them, and time blocking is worth trying if it fits. For teens who struggle, an executive functioning coach or tutor may be more welcome than help from a parent.
My child needs a break after school but is too tired to finish homework after dinner. What can we try?
Naming the problem comes first, Dr. Edlynn suggested: the current plan is not getting the homework finished, so something needs to change. Families can acknowledge the tiredness and invite the child to help solve it, such as doing half before dinner and half after. It also helps to ask what the child thinks.
Do rewards help with homework?
Large rewards for grades may work briefly but tend not to last, Dr. Edlynn explained, because motivation stays external. Rewards can help when shaping a new habit, such as turning in homework or sitting down to study. One example is a reward for a week with no missing assignments. For younger children and children with executive functioning challenges, rewards work best when they come quickly, and they can fade as the habit forms.
How to Find Additional Mental Health Support for Your Child
If anything from Dr. Edlynn’s talk feels close to home, there’s no need to wait until homework struggles start to weigh heavily on your child or your family to ask for help. Getting support early can make a real difference in helping families understand what’s going on and giving kids tools before patterns become more entrenched.
Learn more and request support at cartwheel.org/families
We offer free family webinars throughout the year on topics that matter to parents and caregivers. See what’s coming up and register at cartwheel.org/webinarseries





